Stage 01: Inception & Development
32 items
- Articles9
- Definitions14
- Framework questions6
- Instruments3
Queries stay in your browser.Browse everything

The map
Four catalogues of published material, joined by relationships declared in the content itself. Nothing here is inferred.
01 — 04 · The journey
Every item is filed in the stage it argues about. Between neighbouring stages sits a seam, and the number on it counts the declared links whose two ends sit on either side.
32 items
33 items
30 items
35 items
One item is filed across the whole lifecycle rather than in one stage, in the directory under “Across the lifecycle”.
The seams · 42 links cross a stage
A crossing is a link whose two ends are filed in different stages. Of 231 declared links, 42 cross: 26 at the three seams between neighbouring stages and 16 that skip a stage. 187 stay inside one stage, and 2 touch an item filed across the lifecycle.
Seam 01 → 02
A decision is taken. Nothing has been built and almost nothing has been spent, and the range of what the asset can still cost is at its widest.
Seam 02 → 03
The decision becomes a commitment. What was an option is now a contract, a baseline and a date, and the cost of changing any of them has stopped being small.
Seam 03 → 04
The asset changes hands, and the information does not go with it. This is the heaviest crossing in the corpus, which is what you would expect of the seam where the people who know and the people who are now accountable are two different sets.
The long arc
The consequence of the first decision arrives, decades after anybody involved in taking it has left. It is the second heaviest crossing. Both counts are totals of the declared links, not weights chosen for the drawing.
Two more pairs skip a stage. and . With the four above, that is all 42.
All 42 crossings
8links cross this seam
4links cross this seam
14links cross this seamstrongest
The directory · 131 items
Search the titles and summaries, narrow by kind or stage, or keep only the items with a link that crosses a stage. Open an item’s links to see what it is joined to, and follow any of them.
Business case method already asks for the operating cost and for affordability across the asset's life, and EXPRO's business case procedures, built on HM Treasury's guide, ask for both. What the documents reviewed here do not ask for is a record that the unit which will run the asset has accepted the operating estimate as a claim on its future budget. The capital sum has an approver. The running cost has a description and a statement of support.
Argues for
Saudi Arabia's national manual for asset and facilities management opens by stating that construction is only 20% to 30% of an asset's lifecycle cost. The recommendation it draws from that is correct. The number itself belongs to a family of ratios with a documented provenance problem, and the manual's own argument would be stronger without it.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Almost every instrument the industry owns answers the first question. Estimating, cost control, scheduling, gateways, technical assurance, internal audit, all of them examine execution. Whether this should have been the project at all is settled once, early, by fewer people, and becomes progressively harder to ask.
Argues for
Settles the term
The Green Book states plainly that the appraisal of a project does not need to justify its programme, and the appraisal of a programme does not need to justify its portfolio. That is correct, and it is also why the portfolio, which sets the size of everything below it, is the one level no appraisal is required to justify.
Argues for
Tested by
HM Treasury publishes uplifts by project type, from 24% on a standard building to 200% on equipment and software. The instruction is to start at the upper bound and come down only against verified evidence. The single largest contributory factor it names is not the contractor, the ground or the weather.
Argues for
Settles the term
The standard option appraisal is a table. Options down the side, criteria across the top, weights, scores, a total, a winner. The Green Book names that technique and recommends against it, on the grounds that it lacks an objective basis and reduces transparency. What it recommends instead does not rank options at all. It builds them.
Argues for
Tested by
The UK government reviewed evaluation across the 227 largest projects it runs, together worth £834 billion. A third have a plan capable of finding out whether they worked. Of the three kinds of evaluation, the one asking whether the benefits justified the cost is the weakest, and the reason is that it has to be designed before the project starts.
Argues for
Settles the term
Assurance before anything is built costs less and changes more than assurance anywhere else in the lifecycle. It is also the assurance that is hardest to buy, and the reason is not that owners are careless. It is that inception produces very little of the sort of evidence an assurance function knows how to examine.
Argues for
Settles the term
Early cost estimates are produced as ranges and quoted as commitments. The classification systems behind them say something narrower and more useful. Accuracy is governed by the maturity of the scope definition, and the published ranges exclude the project types a large mixed-use development is made of.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Is there a stated outcome this asset is meant to produce, written down separately from a description of the asset itself?
Argued by
Are the criteria by which options were chosen written down, and is it recorded who was entitled to choose?
Argued by
Does the estimate state the class it was produced at, and does that class match the scope definition actually achieved?
Argued by
Answered with
Has the cost of owning this asset been estimated by, or at least shown to, the people who will have to pay it?
Argued by
Answered with
Has the owner stated what it will need to know in order to run this asset, before the design that produces the information begins?
Argued by
Answered with
Who is entitled to stop this, and have they ever been given information that would let them?
Argued by
Answered with
Apply the published accuracy range for the class your estimate declares to the figure itself, and see where the approved number sits inside it.
Tests
Feeds the question
Apply HM Treasury’s generic optimism bias adjustment for your project type to your own capital estimate and programme, in money and months, at the upper and lower bound, and see which bound the guidance calls the starting point at your stage.
Tests
Feeds the question
Take three real costed buildings and watch the construction share of lifecycle cost move from 66% to 7% while the data stays exactly the same.
Feeds the question
Feeds
A label declaring how mature the scope definition was when an estimate was produced, and therefore how wide its expected accuracy range is.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
An allowance included in an estimate for the cost of risks that are expected to occur but cannot yet be identified individually.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
A cost paired with the probability that it will not be exceeded, read off the cumulative curve produced by a risk simulation.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
All significant and relevant initial and future costs and benefits of an asset across its life, including income, financing and externalities, which is a wider scope than life-cycle cost.
Rests on
A regulatory allowance framework that combines capital and operating expenditure into a single allowance, so a regulated company has no financial reason to prefer building something over operating differently.
The demonstrated, systematic tendency for project appraisers to be over-optimistic about costs, benefits and duration, corrected by an explicit empirically based adjustment.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
The outcome expected if current arrangements continue and the proposal is not implemented, used as the benchmark against which every option is compared.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
The option that just achieves the objectives and goes no further, carried on the shortlist to test whether more ambitious options are worth their additional cost.
An explanation of how a proposal is expected to produce its intended outcomes, setting out the mechanism rather than asserting the result.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
Establishing whether the outcomes a business case promised actually occurred, which requires measurement designed before the project starts.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
Building an estimate from the recorded outcomes of a class of comparable completed projects, rather than from a bottom-up view of the project in front of you.
The third edition of the International Cost Management Standard: a free classification and presentation structure for construction costs, life cycle costs and carbon emissions, agreed by 49 professional bodies.
The US Government Accountability Office guide, GAO-20-195G, setting out the 12 steps of a reliable cost estimating process and the 4 characteristics a credible estimate must display.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
A decision point at the end of a defined stage, at which a named authority decides, against stated evidence and criteria, whether and how the programme proceeds to the next stage.
Rests on
Needs first
A claim for more time turns on three separate questions. Was the contract's notice procedure satisfied? Is the event one for which the contract allows an extension, or whose risk it otherwise places on the employer? Did it actually delay completion? Money is a separate claim, with its own proof of causation and amount. Each question is later tested against what was written down while the event was happening, by whichever party has to prove the point. Records do not create entitlement, a record of an event does not prove that it delayed completion, and the prevention principle does not rescue a claim under every contract or every governing law.
Argues for
A technical score on a qualitative criterion records what evaluators judged. The weighting decides how much of the award that judgement controls; it does not turn the judgement into a measurement. What makes the score answerable is a record that a reader outside the room can test against the solicitation and the proposal, and the instruments examined here require different parts of that record.
Argues for
The WTO agreement, the UNCITRAL Model Law and the EU directive all require the relative importance of the evaluation criteria to appear in the tender documents. None says what the weighting should be, and the Model Law's own commentary calls it discretionary. The GPA and the Model Law specify the arithmetic completely in exactly one situation, an electronic auction, where a machine does the ranking. Meanwhile a 70/30 split under the World Bank's own price formula prices one technical point at 3.4% of the contract and puts a 30 point quality lead beyond the reach of any price at all.
Argues for
Tested by
Government projects are said to run late and over budget while private ones finish. A 2004 study, using what its authors described as the largest dataset of its kind at the time, tested ownership statistically and found privately owned bridges and tunnels escalated more on average than publicly owned ones; its authors called the conventional view an oversimplification. What differs is not the outcome. It is who is counted, and what a private owner has that a public one does not, which is structure rather than virtue.
Argues for
Tested by
A monthly certificate under Saudi Article 109 takes 80 days as the regulation is written, 86 on a real calendar with every office on time, and 128 if one payment order is returned at the wrong moment. On a programme of 1.2bn a year that is 283m to 421m of the contractor's own money standing in the project permanently, borrowed at the contractor's rate, and priced back into the tender. No rule names it, and nothing in the chain prices it.
Argues for
Tested by
The committee that writes the world's dependability standards says reliability should be specified the way dimensions and mass are. Rail has had a published process for specifying and demonstrating it since 2002. The buildings sector's reference specification for what a contractor hands over asks for the manufacturer's projection of how many hours a repair will take, and never how often one will be needed.
Argues for
While a project is being built, its cost lives in two places. The project keeps a record of what has been built and certified. Finance keeps a record of what has been booked. The standards assume they agree. The only thing that makes them agree is a reconciliation, and one auditor has spent 27 years documenting what happens when it is not run.
Argues for
The test for any instrument on a capital programme is whether its output contains something the inputs did not. A rule applied, a calculation done, a source consulted. A rating a team gives itself contains none of these, and colouring it does not add one. One public dashboard has carried both kinds side by side since 2009, and an auditor has re-rated the self-assessed column and published the result.
Argues for
Tested by
When a programme slips, the recovery plan is usually the old plan with later dates on it. That is a translation, not a calculation, and it omits what the evidence says the extension itself costs. A large study of major construction found that each extra year of implementation correlates with cost overrun rising by 4.64%, and a plan that only moves dates has not applied it.
Argues for
Unforeseeable physical conditions is a contract mechanism, not an explanation. The utilities under a site were installed by somebody who holds a record of them, and that record fails to reach the design for a structural reason. The organisation holding it does not bear the cost of it being wrong. Britain priced that failure at 2.4 billion pounds a year before building a national register to fix it.
Argues for
A government builder completed 36 major construction projects and routinely met its cost and schedule goals. It had rebaselined 25 of them, and its reports did not say so. When asked why they had moved a baseline, 4% of project managers gave their own cost or schedule performance as the reason.
Argues for
Tested by
A programme schedule is required to contain the owner's activities as well as the contractor's. A schedule that contains only the contractor's, with the owner's approvals and decisions shown as single milestones or not at all, is incomplete. An incomplete network does not produce an approximate critical path. It produces an invalid one, and it is invalid in a direction that always favours the same party.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Two bodies an owner is likely to cite define contingency and management reserve in opposite directions. One says contingency is for unknown unknowns and sits with the owner. The other treats it as the allowance for what experience says will happen. Both are defensible, and an owner and a contractor using the word across a table are frequently discussing different money, held by different people, against different risks.
Argues for
Settles the term
Delivery assurance measures progress against a baseline. Testing the baseline is a different exercise, and it is the one the monthly report does not contain. A forecast that holds flat and then steps was not stable, it was unexamined, and two numbers usually available in an afternoon will show which.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Clause 8.3 was retitled in the 2024 edition from Outsourcing to externally provided processes, products, technologies and services. The committee says the requirements did not substantially change. The four nouns still describe a category of arrangement wider than what outsourcing usually names, and the wider category is the one nothing in the audit plan is pointed at.
Argues for
Settles the term
A capital programme does not simply contain larger versions of procurement, payment and resourcing. It creates chains that run through all of them, and a chain belongs to no function. That makes under-coverage a design problem in the audit plan rather than a question of materiality, and it has a method attached.
Argues for
Settles the term
The 2024 Standards require an internal audit function to obtain the competencies it does not have, which reads as permission to bring in an engineer. That is the easy half. The obligations that decide whether the exercise was worth commissioning all start after the engineer has arrived.
Argues for
Is the baseline currently being reported against the one that was sanctioned, and if not, is every step between the two documented?
Argued by
Answered with
Are changes assessed before they are made, and does anyone examine changes that were made without being assessed?
Argued by
Does the forecast reflect what is now known, or does it reflect what was committed?
Argued by
Answered with
Where activities that affect the asset have been placed outside the organisation, has the organisation retained the ability to know whether they were done?
Argued by
Answered with
Has anyone examined the seams, as distinct from examining each of the things the seams join?
Argued by
Do the people performing this assurance understand the thing they are examining, and where they do not, is the gap covered by someone who does?
Argued by
Answered with
From planned value, earned value and actual cost, the variances and indices; add the budget at completion for the estimates at completion. Formulas shown and cited.
Tests
Feeds the question
Fed by
Read a Primavera P6 or Microsoft Project export in your browser and see DCMA’s current schedule tests computed on it: open ends, lags, constraints, out-of-sequence progress, status-date faults and missing baselines, each with the activity IDs behind the number.
It does not ask whether the project is healthy. It asks whether the reporting on it has ever produced a signal, across the whole history rather than this month.
Add up the payment periods in the rule that governs your contract, in the unit the rule is written in, and see the wait in calendar days and what financing it costs on every certificate.
Tests
Feeds the question
Take the quality and price split your tender already publishes and see what it commits you to pay for one technical point, the lead no price can close, and the penalty a mid-range bid carries.
Tests
Feeds the question
A statement given against established criteria, by somebody other than the party responsible for the thing being examined, intended to raise the confidence of whoever has to rely on it.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
The approved reference point for scope, cost and schedule against which performance is measured, and the thing every progress report implicitly assumes has not moved.
Rests on
Needed by
Processes, products, technologies and services obtained from outside the organisation that affect the achievement of its asset management objectives.
The US Government Accountability Office guide, GAO-16-89G, setting out 10 best practices for a reliable project schedule and the tests an auditor applies to each.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
A handover contract can test that the information arrived and that the Engineer had no objection to it. That proves receipt. It does not prove that the data passed a schema, that its identifiers reconcile with the finance and maintenance records, or that the receiving system can run a transaction on it. Those are three further tests, and where a contract's information conditions end at delivery and absence of objection, each can fail while those information obligations are performed in full.
Argues for
NASA requires a project work breakdown structure to correlate exactly through seven levels to the financial accounting structure, and EXPRO's cost and commitment procedure reconciles the project cost report to the corporate general ledger on a named form with a named owner. Both requirements are scoped to the project. The Saudi Ministry of Finance's asset manual then has finance allocate the project's cost to assets and components at capitalisation. None of the public documents reviewed here says the project's identifiers stay on the asset record after that.
Argues for
Accounting asks one question at handover, whether the asset is capable of operating as management intended, and answers it with a certificate written for a different purpose. The document that actually tests capability, against the owner's stated requirements, with dates and measurements, is the commissioning file. The two are produced for different purposes and routed to different functions, so they do not meet.
Argues for
Commissioning is the one assurance instrument that measures instead of reads. The standards that require it price its independence in tiers, publish their reasons, and there is a 1,500-building dataset that says what the money buys. It also says less than it used to, which is worth understanding rather than hiding.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
The phrase travels across an office move, a production line, a hospital wing and a finance function taking on a new reporting basis, and it survives the journey by meaning nothing specific in any of them. ISO 55001 already makes it specific, and the arithmetic that falls out is uncomfortable.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
There is a moment when a capital project stops being expenditure and starts being an asset, and it is an accounting entry with a date on it. The standard sets a capability test for that date. Practice mostly uses whichever certificate is nearest, and the two are not the same day.
Argues for
Settles the term
Commissioning is the one handover instrument that tests rather than documents, and it tests the building against the owner's stated requirements. Everything on the other side of the boundary, whether the owner can actually run the thing, has no instrument that tests it, no budget line of its own, and no place on the critical path.
Argues for
Under FIDIC 2017, taking over and contractual acceptance of the works are separate. At taking over the owner takes possession and may begin operating; Sub-Clause 11.9 makes the Performance Certificate the document that constitutes acceptance, and it follows a Defects Notification Period of one year unless the Contract Data states otherwise. A general law-firm summary lists what can change at practical completion or taking over: the contractor's insurance of the works ends, the risk of loss transfers, exposure to delay damages stops, and, where the contract provides for it, retention and the performance bond can begin to release. Where they do, much of the hold on the contractor loosens just as the owner's exposure begins.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Assurance at this stage is triggered by the event that ends the ability to do anything about it. A review three months before taking over can still change what gets produced. The same review afterwards can only describe what is missing, and describing what is missing is not assurance, it is an inventory of the loss.
Argues for
Tested by
Clause 7.7 is new in the 2024 edition and it is the one requirement with a deadline the others do not have. Knowledge is held by people, people leave, and on a programme moving from delivery to ownership the people holding it are employed by somebody else on a contract that is ending.
Argues for
Clauses 7.1 to 7.4 read like human resources boilerplate and get skipped on the way to the interesting parts. They are where the system either becomes real or stays a document, because the decisions that determine asset outcomes are taken in finance, procurement and operations.
Argues for
The gap between what a contractor delivers and what an owner can operate has been measured properly once, more than 20 years ago and on another continent. Of the 15.8bn a year it found, 9.0bn fell on owners and operators, after everyone else had gone. The region now taking delivery at scale has no equivalent number.
Argues for
Settles the term
Was what was delivered tested against what was asked for, by someone who will have to use it?
Argued by
Answered with
Has anyone captured why the asset is the way it is, and what was accepted rather than resolved?
Argued by
Were the contractual conditions for taking over actually met, and where they were not, who agreed to proceed and on what record?
Argued by
Answered with
Can the thing that was built be traced to the thing that appears on the balance sheet, in both directions?
Argued by
Answered with
Does an organisation exist that is capable of operating this asset on the day it is handed over, with people in post?
Argued by
Answered with
Put the questions a readiness review will ask, condition by condition, and name the blockers with their references. The percentage counts your answers; the blockers apply a rule.
Tests
Feeds the question
Fed by
Enter one completion or taking-over date and get every consequential date under your contract regime, each computed from the clause that sets it.
A warranty register that dates every item from its own taking over rather than the project’s, and works out the expiry dates itself.
Tests
Feeds the question
Fed by
Feeds
What has to change hands at taking over, grouped by what it is for rather than by who produced it, with what depends on each item and how to tell whether it is any good.
Tests
Feeds the question
Feeds
Fed by
Describe who your commissioning provider works for and when they were designated, and see where LEED places the arrangement in the edition you choose, v5 or v4, what that position cannot detect, and what commissioning costs on your own project.
Tests
Feeds the question
Feeds
The state in which the organisation taking on an asset can actually operate it from the day it becomes responsible, across its people, resources, processes, systems, risk controls and compliance obligations.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
The record of what was actually constructed, as distinct from what was designed, handed to the owner as a condition of taking over.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
The contractual event under FIDIC at which the Engineer certifies that the works are complete, apart from any minor outstanding work and defects listed in the certificate. The governing contract determines when any defects period starts and when care of the works and the risk of loss or damage pass. It is not acceptance: under the 2017 edition only the Performance Certificate constitutes acceptance of the works.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
The period after taking over during which the employer may notify defects in the works and the contractor is obliged to return and rectify them, called the Defects Liability Period in older forms.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
A standard approved by ANSI as having been developed under its Essential Requirements: ten due-process criteria about how a document is made, none of which concerns what it costs to buy.
Rests on
Needs first
The account holding a project’s accumulated cost during construction, before the completed asset is transferred to property, plant and equipment and depreciation begins.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
The pair of activities that prove an installed asset works: testing checks an item or system against stated criteria, and commissioning is the managed process that verifies the systems work together to meet the owner’s requirements.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
The list, made near completion, of work that is incomplete or does not conform to the contract, each item to be corrected and then checked off; also called a snag list.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
A Saudi government entity can control land without holding a record that places it on the ground. The deed or allocation, the approved plan, the registered map and the valuation report are issued and kept by different bodies, and land described by plan, plot and stated lengths was not fixed in coordinates when its deed was written. Accrual accounting requires the carrying amount to be tied to a parcel whose location and area can be defended. This piece sets out where each record sits, three ways a description can put land in the wrong place, and when a corrected location is a restatement rather than a new estimate.
Argues for
Gross fixed capital formation records the fixed assets acquired in a year, less disposals; in plain terms, investment spending. It does not measure what an asset is worth, what has been completed or what has entered service. Across the asset's lifecycle, its operation, maintenance, information, replacement and eventual disposal are governed and recorded under different rules, in budgets, registers, contracts and accounting records. What the figures show, what they cannot show, and where to look for the rest.
Argues for
Twelve national asset management societies agreed a position statement that says conformance to ISO 55001 may not deliver the value stakeholders want. It names four levels and publishes the characteristics of a mature organisation. It says it is not itself an assessment tool, points to companion guidelines for assessing maturity, and expects each member society to write its own detailed guidance. An owner is better off knowing whose scale produced a maturity score than buying the first ladder they are offered.
Three global bodies govern how infrastructure is meant to be maintained, and each publishes the shape of the calculation without the numbers that make it run. ISO gives a seven-factor equation and says it will not tell you the factors. The World Road Association's free manual on deterioration models is two paragraphs long and points you at your own records. The owner is told the curve decides when to intervene, and is handed no curve. The organisation that solved this owns over 165,000 buildings, and it did not find a curve. It built something that generates one.
Argues for
Componentisation is usually run as a decomposition exercise, and on a large estate a decomposition exercise has no natural end. The question that stops it is not how deep to go but what the asset is. A pole delivers nothing on its own; a road delivers a service, and the pole is part of it. Depth then follows from criticality and from what a payment mechanism has to measure.
Argues for
Settles the term
An entity holding 20bn of real estate sends teams to tag and depreciate 50m of chairs and monitors. The whole annual depreciation of that furniture moves the balance sheet by 0.036%. The 50-year life sitting under the real estate moves it by 100m if it is wrong by a decade, and the standard requires that judgement to be revisited every year.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Where does a desk go? The question sounds trivial and it is not, because a Saudi public entity is asked to hold several registers of the same estate by two different authorities, built on two different organising principles. They are not in conflict. They are in sequence, and treating them as simultaneous is what produces the exercises everybody complains about.
Argues for
Tested by
Settles the term
Clause 6.2.1 gave the SAMP its own requirement in the 2024 edition, and ISO strengthened the leadership clause in the same revision. The two changes belong together. A plan only allocates if somebody senior enough is willing to let it decline something, and a plan that has never declined anything has not been asked to allocate.
Argues for
Settles the term
Where an internal audit function covers the asset base at all, it usually covers maintenance spend and procurement compliance, because those resemble the rest of the audit universe. The decision framework, the plan and the data go unexamined. The organisation ends up assured about how it spends and unassured about what it decided to spend on.
Argues for
The 2024 edition separated actions to address risk from actions to address opportunities, which the 2014 edition ran together in a single subclause. That is not a drafting tidy. When one process has to serve both, loss avoidance wins, because it is the half with a committee, a template and an auditor.
Argues for
Clause 4.5 is new in the 2024 edition and asks for three things, a decision-making framework, the criteria, and the methods. Knowing roughly how things get settled is not the same as being able to produce them, and an option appraisal nobody can audit is not a decision. It is a preference with a spreadsheet attached.
Argues for
The standard states in its own introduction that the order of its requirements implies no order of implementation. That is a defensible position for a standards committee and an expensive one for an organisation standing up an asset management function under compliance pressure.
Argues for
Settles the term
In the 2024 edition Clause 7.6 is data and information, revised and set beside documented information at 7.5. Controlling a record and knowing it is still true are different questions. It is the difference between holding a register and being able to defend one.
Argues for
ISO listed it among the main differences from the 2014 edition, in the flattest language available. The clarification places life cycle management explicitly within operational planning and control.
Argues for
ISO renamed Clause 10.3 and fully technically revised it, which moves the question from whether to intervene to when. That is a different discipline requiring condition data, a view of how things deteriorate, and a funding mechanism that can act before anything has failed. Without all three, running to failure gets described as risk-based.
Argues for
Settles the term
Performance-based maintenance contracts move an owner from paying for activity to paying for a service level. That only works if the owner can already say what it owns, what condition it is in, and what keeping it there should cost. Where it cannot, the risk is not transferred. It is priced back.
Argues for
IPSAS lets a first-time adopter defer recognising its assets while it builds a reliable basis for measuring them. The relief is a runway. A programme procured to produce a valuation, rather than to build a function, arrives at the end of it with a number and no way to keep one.
Argues for
Is there a defined asset management system, and is it written down which assets it covers and which it does not?
Argued by
Can any asset management objective be traced upwards to an organisational objective, and downwards to something someone is doing this year?
Is the data the organisation makes decisions from of a quality anyone has determined, and does anyone know when it was last true?
Argued by
Is the asset management system itself audited, by people competent to audit it, on a programme derived from risk?
Argued by
Does the organisation act on what it expects to happen, or only on what has already happened?
Argued by
Answered with
Do the finance function and the engineering function describe the same asset base in terms that reconcile?
Argued by
The financial register, the technical register and the crosswalk between them, generated together as one Excel workbook. The two registers share the asset tag, and every column states the requirement behind it.
Tests
Feeds the question
Feeds
Fed by
The accounting life, the observed service life and the design life of one item, side by side, with what the difference between them costs a year.
Tests
Feeds the question
Feeds
One building, two treatments the same manual permits, and the gap between the annual charges they produce.
Tests
Feeds the question
Fed by
Feeds
Find the assets that have to be looked at separately, and see what a likelihood times consequence ranking does to that list.
Tests
Feeds the question
Feeds
Read your own register in this page and see when items fall due for renewal, first with every item on a single life and then with lives spread around it.
Tests
Feeds the question
Fed by
Feeds
The set of interrelated elements an organisation uses to establish its asset management policy, objectives and the processes to achieve them.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
Documented information specifying how organisational objectives are converted into asset management objectives, and the role of the asset management system in delivering them.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
Action taken to optimise the timing of an intervention on the basis of expected future condition, rather than in response to something that has already gone wrong.
Rests on
The breaking of an asset into parts that are recognised, valued and depreciated separately, because they have different useful lives.
Rests on
Needs first
Needed by
The IPSASB accrual accounting standard for property, plant and equipment in the public sector, replacing IPSAS 17 for reporting periods beginning on or after 1 January 2025.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
A structured record of the assets an entity owns or controls, carrying the attributes needed to recognise them in the accounts and to operate and maintain them.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
The period over which an asset is expected to be available for use by an entity, which is an accounting estimate about that entity and not a property of the equipment.
Rests on
Needed by
Needs first
Every question this publication asks, drawn from the framework and the articles, filtered by stage and by source, printable.
Feeds the question
Feeds
Method and citation
Four catalogues of this publication: 55 articles, 23 framework questions, 19 instruments and 34 definitions. Each is one item, drawn as one mark.
A link exists only where an item’s own content names another: a framework question lists the articles that argue it; an instrument names the articles it tests, the questions it serves and the instruments it feeds; a definition names the article it rests on and the definitions a reader needs first. The map reads these declarations from the publication’s canonical data and adds no inferred relationships.
The map holds 131 items and 231 declared links, counted from the same data the directory prints. Of those links, 187 have both ends in one stage. A crossing is a link whose ends sit in two different stages: 42 links across 6 pairs of stages. The remaining 2 touch an item filed across the whole lifecycle rather than in one stage, and are counted without being placed on a crossing.
Only the four catalogues are on it. The sources the writing cites, the national manuals index, the pages written for particular roles and the register of what each claim rests on are not items. The map also excludes thematic similarities that neither item declares as a relationship.
The absence of a line means only that neither item names the other. It does not rule out a practical relationship between them. The map records the publication’s declared relationships; it is not a model of project governance.
The map is regenerated from the catalogues on each build. The newest article shown was published or revised on 2 November 2026.
Cite this page
Projects Advisors, “The map: what is joined to what,” https://projects-advisors.com/map