Skip to content
Projects Advisors

Reference · Basis of claims

Every marked claim, sorted by what supports it.

This publication is willing to ask whether a requirement earns its cost. That is worth very little unless a reader can tell which sentences report what a standard says and which are this publication’s analysis.

So every such claim is marked where it appears, and this page collects the marks.

The last group is the one to read first if you came to disagree. Nothing here is a summary; each entry links to the argument it came from.

Basis 01

What the standard requires

52

Quoted or closely paraphrased from a published standard. If one of these is wrong, the standard says otherwise and the error is ours to correct.

The clauses this publication treats are indexed at the standards clauses page.

  1. The land is on the books. Its location is held somewhere else

    The State Properties General Authority's allocation controls define allocation as placing state property at an entity's disposal for use or benefit. State property is land and buildings owned by the state and established by a deed…

    State Properties General Authority, Controls for the Allocation and Recovery of State Properties, board decision Q/1/22/2024, Articles 1 and 9; Organisation of the State Properties General Authority, Council of Ministers decision 266 of 14/5/1442H, Articles 1 and 4

    The registration law's title deed states the property's location, boundaries, description and use, and its map is an engineering survey drawing on a national coordinate system. The register has absolute evidential force and can be…

    Real Estate Registration Law, Royal Decree M/91 of 19/9/1443H, Articles 1, 4, 7, 8 and 39, and decree item 2; Council of Ministers decision 537, item 12

    The Ministry of Justice's guide to converting paper deeds into electronic ones requires the deed's property description to record the plot and plan numbers, the district, the boundaries, the lengths and the area of each plot. Wher…

    Ministry of Justice, guide to the deed-update service on Najiz, 2022, pages 3, 7, 8 and 10

    The registration regulations require the surveyor to place boundary marks for vacant land where its boundaries were not previously marked on the ground by a surveyor, or where those marks have disappeared. The State Properties reg…

    Implementing Regulations of the Real Estate Registration Law, Article 43; Rules and Procedures of the State Properties Register, board decision Q/5/27/2025, Articles 10 and 11

    The registered title records the property's use. An allocated property's use must accord with the approved city plans. The Ministry of Finance's manual lists location, area, surrounding roads, shape and land classification as the…

    Real Estate Registration Law, Article 1; allocation controls, Article 8(1)(a); Ministry of Finance, comprehensive manual for the census and valuation of assets of government entities, second edition, page 67

    The State Properties register is an electronic database integrated with a geographic information system. Deeds must be obtained for state property lying in approved plans or declared zones, and for property allocated to a governme…

    Rules and Procedures of the State Properties Register, first edition, July 2025, Articles 1, 4, 6 and 7

    An item of property, plant and equipment is recognised only if it is probable that future economic benefits or service potential associated with it will flow to the entity and it can be measured reliably. Legal ownership is one in…

    Ministry of Finance, Saudi Public Sector Accounting Standard 45, Property, Plant and Equipment, 2024 edition, paragraph 6 and application guidance AG10 and AG11

    During first-time adoption, an entity may take up to three years to recognise and measure property, plant and equipment it did not recognise under its previous basis. Adjustments arising from events before adoption are recognised…

    Ministry of Finance, Saudi Public Sector Accounting Standard 33, First-time Adoption, 2024 edition, paragraphs 21, 23, 24 and 36

    A prior-period error arises from a failure to use, or a misuse of, reliable information that was available when the statements were authorised and could reasonably have been obtained. A material prior-period error is corrected ret…

    Ministry of Finance, Saudi Public Sector Accounting Standard 3, 2024 edition, paragraphs 7 and 47; Saudi Public Sector Accounting Standard 1, 2024 edition, paragraph 140

    A valuation report must describe the asset clearly, state any limits on inspection and enquiry, state the nature and source of the information relied on, set out how data from the client or from third parties was verified, and sta…

    Saudi Authority for Accredited Valuers, approved report template setting the minimum requirements for a valuation report, issued under the implementing regulations of the Accredited Valuers Law, pages 4 and 5

    The Ministry of Finance's standard construction contract requires as-built drawings to be updated during construction and submitted in editable digital format, CAD and DWF, with one electronic copy, one complete original and six p…

    Ministry of Finance, standard contract for general construction, approved by decision 3652 of 28/08/1441H as amended, clauses 10, 28 and 104; standard contract for engineering design services, clause 75

    On liquidation, the company's records pass to the liquidator, who inventories its assets and liabilities. Liquidation ends when the liquidator's report is approved and takes effect against third parties from deletion from the comm…

    Companies Law, Royal Decree M/132 of 1/12/1443H, Articles 253, 257 and 259

  2. What capital figures record, and what they leave elsewhere

  3. An extension of time is tested against records made during the delay

  4. A delivered file is not an accepted record

  5. The score that is not a number

  6. Operations is told to take part in the business case. Nobody asks it to sign.

    The Green Book asks appraisers to distinguish capital, operating and maintenance costs, and says that practitioners "must make sure that appraisals reflect the appropriate maintenance costs needed to sustain social benefits over t…

    HM Treasury, The Green Book, 2026, paragraphs 6.31 and 6.87 and Table 4

    Operating expenditure estimation is listed among the information to be submitted for review at the end of Stage 2, alongside the Class 4 capital estimate. The economic appraisal is to include revenue costs, defined as "the operati…

    EXPRO, Project Initial Planning Introduction, EPM-S00-GL-000003 Rev 003, page 5; Project Outline Business Case Procedure, EPM-S00-PR-000007 Rev 003, sections 6.1.2.4 and 6.3.1.3, pages 9 and 24

    The statement of capital and revenue requirements "should also indicate the capital sum being requested and, ideally, that the Entity has sufficient income or funding to meet the ongoing costs of the project." Two sections later:…

    EXPRO, Project Outline Business Case Procedure, EPM-S00-PR-000007 Rev 003, sections 6.3.1.3 and 6.3.1.7, pages 24 and 25

    At the entity's strategic outline case, before project stages begin, the need for the asset is to be established together with initial capital and operating expenditure over the asset's life cycle, and the full involvement of asse…

    EXPRO, National Manual for Assets and Facilities Management, Volume 16 Chapter 1, EOM-ZP0-PR-000004-AR Rev 000, sections 6.2.1, 6.3.1, 6.3.2 and 6.3.7, page 10 onward; the Arabic governs and the rendering here is ours

  7. The project crosswalk reaches capitalisation. What survives it?

    For each Agency project, the WBS "must use the NSM numbering scheme and also must correlate exactly through level seven to the corresponding financial accounting structure utilized for each project within the NASA Core Financial S…

    NASA/SP-2016-3404/REV1, Work Breakdown Structure Handbook

    "The cost account is made-up of both WBS, Work Breakdown Structure code and a cost code together", and the control account is that cost account plus the project number. The English revision takes its commodity code from MasterForm…

    EXPRO National Manual for Projects Management, Volume 7 Chapter 2, EPM-KPC-PR-000001 Rev 003

    "Responsibility for the Material, Contract and Subcontract Cost Control process is shared among the following groups: Procurement, Contracts, Engineering, Accounting, and Construction. The ultimate responsibility for cost control…

    EXPRO National Manual for Projects Management, EPM-KPC-PR-000003 Rev 003, section 5.0

    The turnover of facility and infrastructure procedure lists twelve reference documents. Twelve of the twelve are Projects Management documents. Its responsibilities section names eleven parties: the Project Management Team, the De…

    EXPRO National Manual for Projects Management, Volume 16 Chapter 2, EPM-KTC-PR-000001 Rev 003

    Finance owns the process. On receiving the project start memo from project management, it creates a code for the project under which the project's costs accumulate, and keeps a file for every project under execution. Each month it…

    Saudi Ministry of Finance, comprehensive manual for the census and valuation of assets of government entities, second edition, section 2.7, pages 204 to 208

    "Each part of an item of property, plant, and equipment with a cost or value that is significant in relation to the total cost or value of the item shall be depreciated separately." Paragraph 43 adds that an entity depreciating so…

    IPSAS 45, Property, Plant, and Equipment, paragraph 41

    Where an entity recognises the cost of a replacement for part of an item in that item's carrying amount, it "derecognizes the carrying amount of the replaced part regardless of whether the replaced part had been depreciated separa…

    IPSAS 45, paragraph 65

  8. Three award rules make you disclose how the criteria are weighed. None makes you defend it.

  9. The payment chain is a loan, and the contractor is the lender

    The contractor prepares a monthly or provisional statement and submits it to the consultant. The consultant verifies the works on site and reports within ten working days, "عشرة أيام عمل". The government agency completes its appro…

    Executive Regulations of the Government Tenders and Procurement Law, Article 109, read in the Arabic text published by the Ministry of Finance

    Where an employer pays late, FIDIC entitles the contractor to "financing charges compounded monthly on the amount unpaid during the period of delay", running from the date for payment "irrespective ... of the date on which any Int…

    FIDIC Conditions of Contract 1999, Sub-Clause 14.8, as stated in FIDIC's own question and answer service for the 1999 suite; Saudi Central Bank policy rates read at sama.gov.sa

    Article 127 closes government offices from the 25th of Ramadan to the end of the 5th of Shawwal, and from the 5th of Dhu al-Hijjah to the end of the 15th, and sets the weekly rest at Friday and Saturday. Article 128 adds that a si…

    Executive Regulations for Human Resources in the Civil Service, Articles 127 and 128, read in the Arabic; Ministry of Human Resources and Social Development, Holidays and Leaves, the ministry's own labour education page for the business sector

    The Engineer certifies "the amount which the Engineer fairly determines to be due", so a statement is not thrown back because part of it is disputed: the disputed part is trimmed, the rest is certified, and where work is not in ac…

    FIDIC Conditions of Contract for Construction 1999, Sub-Clauses 14.6 to 14.8, via a free clause commentary and FIDIC's own question and answer service for the 1999 suite; Saudi Government Tenders and Procurement Law and its Executive Regulations, searched in full in the Arabic

    The Law permits an advance payment against a bank guarantee equal to its value. Article 108 sets the terms: يجوز, may, not shall, the government authority may disburse an advance payment not exceeding 10% of the total contract val…

    Executive Regulations of the Government Tenders and Procurement Law, Article 108, read in the Arabic; the Law's own provision on advance payment read in the same file

  10. Reliability can be specified like mass. Building owners do not.

  11. The certified value and the booked value are two different records

  12. A dashboard computed from your own beliefs is not information

  13. Conformance is not maturity, and the body that says so is selling nothing

  14. Nobody will give you a deterioration curve

  15. The only test the building ever gets

  16. A lighting pole in the desert is not an asset

  17. Counting desks while the useful life goes unexamined

  18. Moving a date is not the same as re-planning

  19. The ground was always there. The record was not.

  20. An entity is asked for four asset registers and builds one

Basis 02

Why the standard says so

25

The standard-setter’s own stated reason, from a Basis for Conclusions, a committee note or an audit appendix. Not our explanation of the rule, theirs.

  1. An extension of time is tested against records made during the delay

  2. Operations is told to take part in the business case. Nobody asks it to sign.

  3. The project crosswalk reaches capitalisation. What survives it?

  4. Three award rules make you disclose how the criteria are weighed. None makes you defend it.

  5. Private projects overrun too. The difference is who counts.

  6. The payment chain is a loan, and the contractor is the lender

  7. A dashboard computed from your own beliefs is not information

  8. Conformance is not maturity, and the body that says so is selling nothing

  9. The only test the building ever gets

  10. Moving a date is not the same as re-planning

  11. The ground was always there. The record was not.

  12. The date a project becomes an asset is not the date on the certificate

  13. A strategic asset management plan that has never stopped anything is a description

  14. Every organisation has a risk register. Ask for the other one

  15. ISO 55001 now requires you to write down how you decide

  16. Knowledge has a departure date

  17. Nothing tells you when a record stopped being true

  18. Operational control now says life cycle management, which is a larger change than it looks

  19. Preventive became predictive, and the second needs three things the first did not

  20. You can place the activity outside. You cannot place the accountability there

Basis 03

Required, and not being done

7

A requirement shown by a named dataset to be substantially unmet. These are claims about the world rather than about a document, so each carries the dataset and its limitations.

  1. Private projects overrun too. The difference is who counts.

  2. The certified value and the booked value are two different records

  3. A dashboard computed from your own beliefs is not information

  4. Every programme performs well against a baseline it can move

Basis 05

Our reading, not a standard

38

This publication’s own analysis, argued on the page. No standard requires it, and readers can disagree with it without contradicting one.

  1. The land is on the books. Its location is held somewhere else

  2. What capital figures record, and what they leave elsewhere

  3. An extension of time is tested against records made during the delay

  4. A delivered file is not an accepted record

  5. The score that is not a number

  6. Operations is told to take part in the business case. Nobody asks it to sign.

  7. The project crosswalk reaches capitalisation. What survives it?

  8. Three award rules make you disclose how the criteria are weighed. None makes you defend it.

  9. Private projects overrun too. The difference is who counts.

  10. The payment chain is a loan, and the contractor is the lender

  11. Reliability can be specified like mass. Building owners do not.

  12. The certified value and the booked value are two different records

  13. A dashboard computed from your own beliefs is not information

  14. Conformance is not maturity, and the body that says so is selling nothing

  15. Nobody will give you a deterioration curve

  16. The only test the building ever gets

  17. A lighting pole in the desert is not an asset

  18. Counting desks while the useful life goes unexamined

  19. Moving a date is not the same as re-planning

  20. The ground was always there. The record was not.

  21. An entity is asked for four asset registers and builds one

  22. Operational readiness has seven conditions. Handover delivers two.

  23. Nothing tells you when a record stopped being true

  24. You can place the activity outside. You cannot place the accountability there

Correspondence

If something here is wrong, that is worth more than agreement.

Material errors are corrected on the affected pages. Messages are used to reply, not to build a mailing list.