Skip to content
Projects Advisors

Stage 01 · The Lifecycle

Inception & Development

Almost nothing has been built, and almost everything has been decided.

The stage

What happens at this stage

The inception stage is short, cheap and disproportionately consequential. Location, configuration, procurement route, delivery model and the basic operating concept are all fixed here. Where they are fixed by a small group under time pressure, they can be settled before anyone who will operate the asset has been consulted.

The cost of changing any of these decisions is close to zero at this point. It never gets lower. Every subsequent stage adds commitment, and commitment is what converts a decision into a constraint.

The failure this publication looks for here is not poor analysis. It is that the questions asked at inception are all delivery questions: what will it cost, how long will it take, who will build it. The questions that determine whole-life outcomes are ownership questions, and it may be that no one in the room is yet accountable for them.

What goes wrong

What typically goes wrong

  1. The operator has no voice in a brief that determines their next 30 years.

  2. A concept-grade estimate is adopted as a budget. For building and general construction, AACE 56R-08 puts a Class 5 estimate as wide as -30% to +50%; treating that as a commitment builds failure into the baseline.

  3. Whole-life cost is acknowledged in principle and excluded from the decision in practice.

  4. Information requirements are never specified, so nobody is contractually obliged to produce them later.

Questions to ask

Questions worth asking

  • Who in this process is accountable for what the asset costs to run?

  • What class of estimate is this, and what range is attached to it?

  • What information will we need at handover, and where is it specified?

  • What are we deciding now that we will not be able to revisit?

Writing

Writing on inception

9 articles

  1. Operations is told to take part in the business case. Nobody asks it to sign.Business case method already asks for the operating cost and for affordability across the asset's life, and EXPRO's business case procedures, built on HM Treasury's guide, ask for both. What the documents reviewed here do not ask for is a record that the unit which will run the asset has accepted the operating estimate as a claim on its future budget. The capital sum has an approver. The running cost has a description and a statement of support.16 min read
  2. A lifecycle ratio nobody can check, and a conclusion that does not need itSaudi Arabia's national manual for asset and facilities management opens by stating that construction is only 20% to 30% of an asset's lifecycle cost. The recommendation it draws from that is correct. The number itself belongs to a family of ratios with a documented provenance problem, and the manual's own argument would be stronger without it.7 min read
  3. Doing the project right, and doing the right projectAlmost every instrument the industry owns answers the first question. Estimating, cost control, scheduling, gateways, technical assurance, internal audit, all of them examine execution. Whether this should have been the project at all is settled once, early, by fewer people, and becomes progressively harder to ask.7 min read
  4. Every appraisal can be right and the portfolio still wrongThe Green Book states plainly that the appraisal of a project does not need to justify its programme, and the appraisal of a programme does not need to justify its portfolio. That is correct, and it is also why the portfolio, which sets the size of everything below it, is the one level no appraisal is required to justify.7 min read
  5. The largest contributor to optimism bias is the document that starts the projectHM Treasury publishes uplifts by project type, from 24% on a standard building to 200% on equipment and software. The instruction is to start at the upper bound and come down only against verified evidence. The single largest contributory factor it names is not the contractor, the ground or the weather.7 min read
  6. Weighting and scoring is the method the guidance warns againstThe standard option appraisal is a table. Options down the side, criteria across the top, weights, scores, a total, a winner. The Green Book names that technique and recommends against it, on the grounds that it lacks an objective basis and reduces transparency. What it recommends instead does not rank options at all. It builds them.7 min read
  7. Whether it was worth doing is the least evaluated questionThe UK government reviewed evaluation across the 227 largest projects it runs, together worth £834 billion. A third have a plan capable of finding out whether they worked. Of the three kinds of evaluation, the one asking whether the benefits justified the cost is the weakest, and the reason is that it has to be designed before the project starts.7 min read
  8. A gate that has never been failed is not a controlAssurance before anything is built costs less and changes more than assurance anywhere else in the lifecycle. It is also the assurance that is hardest to buy, and the reason is not that owners are careless. It is that inception produces very little of the sort of evidence an assurance function knows how to examine.7 min read
  9. An estimate is a measure of how well the scope is definedEarly cost estimates are produced as ranges and quoted as commitments. The classification systems behind them say something narrower and more useful. Accuracy is governed by the maturity of the scope definition, and the published ranges exclude the project types a large mixed-use development is made of.8 min read

Every stage, in one index

Reference

Terms this stage relies on

14 terms

Every definition, in one index

The seam that follows · Development to delivery

Between inception and delivery, intent becomes specification, and whatever was never written down stops existing.

28days

to give notice of a claim under the 1999 and 2017 FIDIC conditions, counted from awareness of the event. A record of an event does not prove that it delayed completion.

Source · FIDIC Conditions of Contract, Sub-Clause 20.1 (1999) and 20.2 (2017)