What goes wrong without it
This requirement was added to ISO 55001 in its 2024 edition, and it asks for something that may exist only as habit. Without recorded criteria, an option appraisal cannot be audited: there is no standard against which to say the wrong option was selected, only a preference against a preference. It also makes delegation invisible, so nobody can establish afterwards whether the person who committed the money was entitled to.
What to examine
5 tests
- Ask for the documented decision-making criteria. Their absence is itself a nonconformity against ISO 55001:2024, not merely a weakness.
- Check that the criteria cover the whole life of the asset and not only capital cost. Criteria that stop at delivery will select assets that are cheap to build and expensive to own.
- Trace one significant option decision back through the criteria and confirm the recorded rationale matches them.
- Confirm delegation limits exist in writing, and test one commitment against them.
- Check the methods and tools used are stated, since the standard requires these alongside the criteria.
Required by
- ISO 55001:2024, Clause 4.5, asset management decision-making, comprising 4.5.1 Framework, 4.5.2 Criteria and 4.5.3 Methods, processes and tools. This subclause is new in the second edition; it has no counterpart in ISO 55001:2014.
- PMBOK Guide, Eighth Edition, November 2025, which carries governance as one of its seven performance domains.
- ISO 21502:2020, Clause 6, on the project governance framework.
Read the sources
- ISO 55001:2024, asset management system requirements
2024 edition; read 2026-09-26. ISO’s product page: the publication details and ISO’s own summary of the standard, not the requirement text. The contents, foreword and introduction cited in this publication are taken from the standard’s preview pages hosted on the ANSI webstore, not from this page.
How the method applies it
A record of the method: Lifecycle decision and conditions record, used at Renewal or replacement decision.
direct The means produces evidence at least one of the tests above asks for. A reading, and labelled as one.
In the asset lifecycle methodThe steps of the two methods that this domain examines.
Cite this page
Projects Advisors, “01.2 The decision-making framework,” revised 2026-10-08, https://projects-advisors.com/framework/inception-and-development/decision-making-framework
