Skip to content
Projects Advisors

The argument

Value is lost at the joins.

A major physical asset passes through four stages. Each is run by different people, measured by different things, and accountable for different outcomes. This publication’s argument concentrates on what can be lost between them.

At each seam, something has to be carried across: intent, then accountability, then understanding.

At each seam, too, the party that has held it may be approaching the end of its obligations as the next party comes to depend on it. This page is the whole argument in one place. Every article on this site examines a seam or a stage, and some carry the argument across more than one. The argument as a sequence of steps: the method.

Stage 01Inception & DevelopmentAlmost nothing has been built, and almost everything has been decided.Writing on Inception

What typically goes wrong

  1. The operator has no voice in a brief that determines their next 30 years.
  2. A concept-grade estimate is adopted as a budget. For building and general construction, AACE 56R-08 puts a Class 5 estimate as wide as -30% to +50%; treating that as a commitment builds failure into the baseline.
  3. Whole-life cost is acknowledged in principle and excluded from the decision in practice.
  4. Information requirements are never specified, so nobody is contractually obliged to produce them later.
Stage 02Delivery & ControlsHeavy reporting, and less clarity than the reporting suggests.Writing on Delivery

What typically goes wrong

  1. Progress is reported against a baseline that the team already regards as obsolete.
  2. Change is managed as a commercial event rather than as information about the design.
  3. Entitlement is accumulated rather than resolved, so a dispute is quietly manufactured during delivery and argued about years later.
  4. Risk registers list risks without anybody owning the decision each risk implies.
Stage 03Handover & TransitionA short seam, with long consequences.Writing on Handover

What typically goes wrong

  1. Everything required is delivered, and nothing needed is transferred.
  2. As-built information records what was drawn rather than what was installed.
  3. Late changes are documented commercially but never reflected in the operating record.
  4. The operating team is assembled after the handover it should have specified.
Stage 04Operations & Asset ManagementThe longest stage, and one that inception may not have planned for.Writing on Operations

What typically goes wrong

  1. The asset register is a spreadsheet that one person maintains and nobody audits.
  2. The fixed asset register and the technical asset register describe the same assets differently, and nobody owns the reconciliation.
  3. Assets are valued for the balance sheet without ever being physically located, tagged or condition-assessed.
  4. Condition is assessed once at handover and never again.

The consequence

Nothing about the decision changed. Only when it was examined.

The practical consequence of the four stages is a single curve. The cost of reversing a decision rises slowly through inception and delivery, then steeply once an asset is operating. The steep section begins at handover, as the delivery project, and the reviews attached to it, draw to a close.

The cost of reversing a decision rises slowly through inception and delivery, then steeply once the asset is operating; the steep section begins at handover.The cost of reversing a decision, plotted across the lifecycle. Drawn as a shape, not to a scale.Projects Advisors. Reuse: https://projects-advisors.com/licence01 Inception02 Delivery03 Handover04 Operations
Figure The cost of reversing a decision, plotted across the lifecycle. Drawn as a shape, not to a scale.

Stage 01

The decisions taken before anything is built, and the operating consequences they quietly fix in place.

Writing on Inception

Stage 02

Governance, cost, schedule and risk during construction, and the difference between progress and health.

Writing on Delivery

Stage 03

The seam where information, accountability and intent change hands.

Writing on Handover

Stage 04

Knowing what you own, where it is, what condition it is in, and what it will cost to keep.

Writing on Operations
Read the writing behind this