
Lifecycle cost sensitivity
Take three real costed buildings and watch the construction share of lifecycle cost move from 66% to 7% while the data stays exactly the same.
The seam
The business case that quotes a lifecycle ratio to justify spending more at design, and the reader who cannot tell whether the ratio means anything because nobody said what is in the denominator.

The instrument
Construction is 20% to 30% of an asset's lifecycle cost. The claim is in national manuals and business cases, and it is used to argue for spending more at design, which is a good argument. It is almost never published with a denominator, and without one it cannot be checked.
These are three real office buildings, costed over 25 years by four researchers at Reading, discounted to a common base date, published free and itemised line by line. Nothing below changes the data. Move the boundary and construction is 66% of lifecycle cost, or 25%, or 7%. Why the ratio was unusable before anybody did this.
Three UK offices at 1999 prices. The authors say each building has its own ratio, which is most of the point.
The source costed 25. Anything else spreads its totals evenly, which is crude, and the note below says how crude.
Counting the building in use, construction is 25% of Building A's lifecycle cost over 25 years.
That falls inside the quoted 20% to 30% band, so on this reading the claim holds for this building. Across the three scope boundaries and nothing else, the share on this building runs from 7% to 66.3%, a factor of 9.5.
| Cost | Amount | Counted |
|---|---|---|
| Construction, including land, finance, design | 7,712,937 | in |
| Maintenance and replacement | 3,915,766 | in |
| Running the building | 19,189,175 | in |
| Salaries of the people inside it | 79,624,677 | out |
| Total in your denominator | 30,817,878 | 25% construction |
In the notation the literature argues in, this building is 1 : 0.5 : 12.8. The famous ratio is 1:5:200, which was published without data, could not be replicated, and was described by the people who tried as an urban myth. The paper reproduced here found 1:0.5:12.8, 1:0.4:13 and 1:0.3:9.4 on three real buildings.
Three statements are needed beside any ratio, and this page can only supply two of them honestly. The scope is yours to set and the period is yours to set. Whether the flows are discounted is not offered as a control, because these figures are already discounted to a common base date and the source does not publish the annual profile that would let anybody rediscount them. What it does say is that with finance costs omitted and the money flows left undiscounted, Building A comes out at about 1 : 1 : 30 rather than 1 : 0.5 : 12.8. Quoting that is honest; building a slider on top of it would not be.
There is a fix for this, and it is free. The scope boundary is not unfixable, it is unstated, and ICMS 3 exists to state it: an international standard for classifying and presenting life cycle costs, agreed through the ICMS Coalition by 49 professional bodies, published in full at no cost with its Basis for Conclusions alongside. A ratio whose terms are mapped to a published classification can be compared with another one. A ratio whose terms are not can only be repeated.
What travels with the data. Three buildings is not a sample. UK offices, 1999 prices, 25 years, finance costs included. The authors state their own limits: no regional variation in construction, location or staff costs, and business costs that may omit items such as employer contributions. Their conclusion is that every building has a unique ratio, which is the argument against quoting any single one, this page's included.
Lifecycle cost sensitivity
projects-advisors.com/tools/lifecycle-ratio
- Building
- Building A
- Period
- 25 years
- Scope boundary
- The building in use
- Construction share
- 25%
Building A, 25 years, counting the building in use. Construction is 25% of lifecycle cost, and the ratio is 1 : 0.5 : 12.8. Across the three scope boundaries and no other change, the share runs 7% to 66.3%, a factor of 9.5. Computed in the browser from published data at projects-advisors.com/tools/lifecycle-ratio
| Building | The building only | The building in use | Everything the building carries |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building A | 66.3% | 25% | 7% |
| Building B | 72.4% | 28.4% | 6.9% |
| Building C | 79.6% | 38.7% | 9.4% |
Computed from
- Hughes, Ancell, Gruneberg and Hirst, Exposing the myth of the 1:5:200 ratio, ARCOM 2004 (ARCOM 2004; read 2026-09-04)https://www.arcom.ac.uk/-docs/proceedings/ar2004-0373-0381_Hughes_et_al.pdf
- ICMS 3, International Cost Management Standard, life cycle costs and carbon (third edition, 2021; read 2026-08-29)https://icms-coalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/icms_3rd_edition_final.pdf
Computed in your browser. Nothing you enter is sent to Projects Advisors or to anyone else.
What it takes, and what it gives
What you supply
- Which of three published buildings to use
- Where the denominator stops: the fabric, the running costs, or the people
- How many years to spread the operating costs over
What you get
- Construction as a share of lifecycle cost, and the ratio in the notation the literature uses
- How far that share moves across the scope boundaries, on one building
- Whether the quoted 20% to 30% band survives on each building
Basis
What this computes from
Every document below is named in full. The link is a convenience on top of the citation.
All the sourcesRead the sources
- Hughes, Ancell, Gruneberg and Hirst, Exposing the myth of the 1:5:200 ratio, ARCOM 2004
ARCOM 2004; read 2026-09-04. Free in full. The paper that could not replicate 1:5:200 and published costed data for three real office buildings instead, over 25 years, discounted to a common base date and with finance costs included. Table 4 gives construction, maintenance, replacement, other occupancy and aggregate wages separately, which is what makes the scope boundary testable rather than arguable. Its measured ratios are 1:0.5:12.8, 1:0.4:13 and 1:0.3:9.4. The authors state their own limitations, including no regional variation and possibly incomplete business costs. - ICMS 3, International Cost Management Standard, life cycle costs and carbon
third edition, 2021; read 2026-08-29. Free. Agreed by 49 professional bodies through the ICMS Coalition, which RICS convenes.
Cite this page
Projects Advisors, “Lifecycle cost sensitivity,” revised 2026-11-02, https://projects-advisors.com/tools/lifecycle-ratio
What the output feeds
The argument this tool tests
A lifecycle ratio nobody can check, and a conclusion that does not need it- Framework domain 01.4: Whole-life cost and the operating consequence
The next tool in the chain
Componentisation calculator