Skip to content
Projects Advisors

By role · Cost controller

Two guides tell you how to build the number. Neither follows it past handover.

The free GAO cost and schedule guides set out what a defensible estimate and a defensible schedule look like. Both are about a project, and a project ends.

Who this is for

You own the estimate, the baseline and the forecast, and you are asked every month whether the number is still good. The honest answer depends on things that are not in your cost system.

What you already work under

Standards governing your work

  1. GAO Cost Estimating and Assessment Guide, GAO-20-195G, March 2020, free in full

    Four characteristics of a reliable estimate, comprehensive, well documented, accurate and credible, and a twelve-step process for producing one. It is explicit that an estimate without a documented basis is not an estimate.

  2. GAO Schedule Assessment Guide, GAO-16-89G, December 2015, free in full

    Ten best practices for a schedule that can carry a forecast, including capturing all activities, sequencing them, establishing the critical path and conducting a schedule risk analysis. The test it applies is whether the schedule can be used to predict, not whether it can be used to report.

  3. ICMS 3, International Cost Management Standard, free in full with its Basis for Conclusions, agreed by 49 professional bodies

    A classification and presentation structure for life cycle costs and carbon, so that construction, renewal, operation, maintenance and end-of-life costs are reported in comparable categories. It settles how costs are grouped and reported. It does not undertake to control them.

Read the sources

Where that stops

The two GAO guides are project instruments and stop at the end of the project. ICMS 3 covers the whole life and is a classification standard: it tells you how to structure and present the cost, not how to hold it. Between them sits the question you will actually be asked, which is whether the money being spent this month is buying the thing the operating budget was set for. None of these standards covers that join, so the material below is arranged across it rather than either side of it.

The reading path

The material, on the same lifecycle spine as everything else.

Whether the estimate is a measure of the cost or a measure of how little is yet known, and whether the whole-life figure beside it rests on anything.

Instruments

  • Lifecycle cost sensitivity

    Take three real costed buildings and watch the construction share of lifecycle cost move from 66% to 7% while the data stays exactly the same.

Related writing

  1. An estimate is a measure of how well the scope is definedEarly cost estimates are produced as ranges and quoted as commitments. The classification systems behind them say something narrower and more useful. Accuracy is governed by the maturity of the scope definition, and the published ranges exclude the project types a large mixed-use development is made of.8 min read
  2. A lifecycle ratio nobody can check, and a conclusion that does not need itSaudi Arabia's national manual for asset and facilities management opens by stating that construction is only 20% to 30% of an asset's lifecycle cost. The recommendation it draws from that is correct. The number itself belongs to a family of ratios with a documented provenance problem, and the manual's own argument would be stronger without it.7 min read
  3. The largest contributor to optimism bias is the document that starts the projectHM Treasury publishes uplifts by project type, from 24% on a standard building to 200% on equipment and software. The instruction is to start at the upper bound and come down only against verified evidence. The single largest contributory factor it names is not the contractor, the ground or the weather.7 min read
  4. Every appraisal can be right and the portfolio still wrongThe Green Book states plainly that the appraisal of a project does not need to justify its programme, and the appraisal of a programme does not need to justify its portfolio. That is correct, and it is also why the portfolio, which sets the size of everything below it, is the one level no appraisal is required to justify.7 min read

Whether the variance you are reporting is against a baseline that has held, and whether the forecast has ever moved for a reason.

Instruments

  • Earned value calculator

    From planned value, earned value and actual cost, the variances and indices; add the budget at completion for the estimates at completion. Formulas shown and cited.

  • Reporting history check

    It does not ask whether the project is healthy. It asks whether the reporting on it has ever produced a signal, across the whole history rather than this month.

  • Payment chain calculator

    Add up the payment periods in the rule that governs your contract, in the unit the rule is written in, and see the wait in calendar days and what financing it costs on every certificate.

  • What a technical point is worth

    Take the quality and price split your tender already publishes and see what it commits you to pay for one technical point, the lead no price can close, and the penalty a mid-range bid carries.

Related writing

  1. Every programme performs well against a baseline it can moveA government builder completed 36 major construction projects and routinely met its cost and schedule goals. It had rebaselined 25 of them, and its reports did not say so. When asked why they had moved a baseline, 4% of project managers gave their own cost or schedule performance as the reason.9 min read
  2. A forecast that never moves is not stable, it is unexaminedDelivery assurance measures progress against a baseline. Testing the baseline is a different exercise, and it is the one the monthly report does not contain. A forecast that holds flat and then steps was not stable, it was unexamined, and two numbers usually available in an afternoon will show which.6 min read
  3. Your contingency and their contingency are different moneyTwo bodies an owner is likely to cite define contingency and management reserve in opposite directions. One says contingency is for unknown unknowns and sits with the owner. The other treats it as the allowance for what experience says will happen. Both are defensible, and an owner and a contractor using the word across a table are frequently discussing different money, held by different people, against different risks.7 min read
  4. Moving a date is not the same as re-planningWhen a programme slips, the recovery plan is usually the old plan with later dates on it. That is a translation, not a calculation, and it omits what the evidence says the extension itself costs. A large study of major construction found that each extra year of implementation correlates with cost overrun rising by 4.64%, and a plan that only moves dates has not applied it.9 min read
  5. The critical path cannot show a delay nobody scheduledA programme schedule is required to contain the owner's activities as well as the contractor's. A schedule that contains only the contractor's, with the owner's approvals and decisions shown as single milestones or not at all, is incomplete. An incomplete network does not produce an approximate critical path. It produces an invalid one, and it is invalid in a direction that always favours the same party.8 min read
  6. The ground was always there. The record was not.Unforeseeable physical conditions is a contract mechanism, not an explanation. The utilities under a site were installed by somebody who holds a record of them, and that record fails to reach the design for a structural reason. The organisation holding it does not bear the cost of it being wrong. Britain priced that failure at 2.4 billion pounds a year before building a national register to fix it.9 min read
  7. Private projects overrun too. The difference is who counts.Government projects are said to run late and over budget while private ones finish. A 2004 study, using what its authors described as the largest dataset of its kind at the time, tested ownership statistically and found privately owned bridges and tunnels escalated more on average than publicly owned ones; its authors called the conventional view an oversimplification. What differs is not the outcome. It is who is counted, and what a private owner has that a public one does not, which is structure rather than virtue.15 min read
  8. The payment chain is a loan, and the contractor is the lenderA monthly certificate under Saudi Article 109 takes 80 days as the regulation is written, 86 on a real calendar with every office on time, and 128 if one payment order is returned at the wrong moment. On a programme of 1.2bn a year that is 283m to 421m of the contractor's own money standing in the project permanently, borrowed at the contractor's rate, and priced back into the tender. No rule names it, and nothing in the chain prices it.25 min read
  9. Three award rules make you disclose how the criteria are weighed. None makes you defend it.The WTO agreement, the UNCITRAL Model Law and the EU directive all require the relative importance of the evaluation criteria to appear in the tender documents. None says what the weighting should be, and the Model Law's own commentary calls it discretionary. The GPA and the Model Law specify the arithmetic completely in exactly one situation, an electronic auction, where a machine does the ranking. Meanwhile a 70/30 split under the World Bank's own price formula prices one technical point at 3.4% of the contract and puts a 30 point quality lead beyond the reach of any price at all.12 min read
  10. An extension of time is tested against records made during the delayA claim for more time turns on three separate questions. Was the contract's notice procedure satisfied? Is the event one for which the contract allows an extension, or whose risk it otherwise places on the employer? Did it actually delay completion? Money is a separate claim, with its own proof of causation and amount. Each question is later tested against what was written down while the event was happening, by whichever party has to prove the point. Records do not create entitlement, a record of an event does not prove that it delayed completion, and the prevention principle does not rescue a claim under every contract or every governing law.14 min read

Whether the cost you are closing out becomes an asset value somebody else can defend, and which clocks start on the date you certify.

Instruments

Whether the renewal profile the entity is about to commit to is a forecast or a straight line, and what the assumption behind it is worth.

Instruments

  • Renewal profile

    Read your own register in this page and see when items fall due for renewal, first with every item on a single life and then with lives spread around it.

  • Three lives for the same asset

    The accounting life, the observed service life and the design life of one item, side by side, with what the difference between them costs a year.

  • Criticality screen

    Find the assets that have to be looked at separately, and see what a likelihood times consequence ranking does to that list.

In the asset lifecycle method

The steps at which the project controls family acts in the asset lifecycle method, 2 in all, by stage and seam: what it does, in which capacity, and whether the assignment is required, analysis or the organisation’s own decision. A family is a kind of work, not this role’s job description; each listed step contains the proposition on which the assignment is based.

Delivery & Controls

Where the project controls function acts in the method

This page composes material published elsewhere on this site and adds no claim of its own. The arrangement into stages is this publication’s, as the framework says at length; the requirements above are quoted from documents that are free to read and linked next to each. Where a stage is empty for this role, it says so rather than being left out.